Post image for Why couldn’t he have just been honest?

Why couldn’t he have just been honest?

by Emma on January 4, 2012

In this article Emma addresses the significant others of crossdressers. 

If you’re stumbling across this article because you are feeling lost, lonely, confused, frightened, or frantic due to the discovery of your husband or significant other’s hidden crossdressing needs I would love for you to pause and take this article in. I will try to help you dissect this situation in a loving, if not logical, manner.

I spent nearly the entire scope of all of my relationships as a heavily closeted crossdresser, and when I finally came out to my most recent significant other she could not understand why I didn’t divulge at the very beginning of the relationship. She felt as though she could have made an entirely different set of life decisions that did not anchor her to a person that was harboring such a HUGE secret. A whirlwind of questions tore through her head: “Is my husband gay? Does he want to become a woman? What will this do to our family? Will I find another man if we split? Will he lose his job if he wants to be more open?” She had absolutely no clues beforehand, and one catastrophic hypothetical scenario evolved into another, she reacted as though someone had set her dream house ablaze. For a very long while I felt as though I had done it…

I came out of the closet to my wife in my mid twenties. I know that some of you may be getting this information much later in life. I guess I am a little different, I knew in the back of my mind that I was going to eventually transition and I had to let that cat out of the bag way sooner than later. Now you’re probably asking yourself: “Hey, whoa! That’s bad! Why would you even get married and start a family?!” Well, I won’t justify my case, but I will help you step through the labyrinth that is the mind of a trans* person in the closet by presenting a few of the things that I was thinking that pushed me well into marriage and family life, and why it was that those ways of thinking failed.

Love will keep me happy and satisfied.

Why it failed: It is a fact that love alone is NOT enough. Anyone who has been through the relationship ringer understands that they have ups and downs, and certain contingencies must be met for things to work in difficult times. Some of the cornerstones of a successful relationship are: You must accept each other for the people that you really are, you must attempt to remain attractive in the eyes of your significant other, and you have to live honestly with each other. These foundations of a relationship are compromised by harboring such a pervasive secret.

I am supposed to start a family, get a job, pay taxes, and then die.

Why it failed: This was a simple belief that was passed on to me by my parents. I knew I wanted a child of my own blood, but I also understood that I was in no way the best candidate for fatherhood. I would dismiss my doubts by asking myself something like, “Well, trans people in the past must have been successful at suppressing their feelings and leading a ‘normal’ life, adhering to societal expectations, right?” It turns out that that was not always the case, and trans people aren’t the standard bearers of societal expectation.

If I say anything, this will all fall apart.

Why it failed: I eventually began to feel more selfish for keeping my secrets than being honest about whom I really was. After coming out things did actually fall apart. Everything falling apart is likely the perpetuating worry behind continuation of the misinformation, sneaking around, and covering up.  I know it was the reason for all of mine. I wanted the best of both worlds, and it turns out that you can’t always have it all (duh!). After coming out we concluded that I was not the person she married. You must take a very long while to reflect upon the person you married and the person who confronts you now. Has it been a while since you found out? Has he changed? Is he a she? Is he just a he that sometimes dresses like a she to blow off steam? Has this made him a better person? Worse? Even though my situation has ended rather badly, I have to say that we do both now look forward to our separate futures.

I can just die with my secret.

Why it failed: Harboring such a secret is an incredibly toxic practice. Every day I thought about being a girl. Your husband or boyfriend may think about dressing as a girl, or enjoying the sensation of silk and lace every day as well. There is no safe way to stifle something that so consumes a person every day.

Society will reject me.

Why it failed: Although there is a stigma on trans people, “They’re perverted, they hate their fathers, they can’t be trusted…” I had no actual real life points of reference. I would very rarely steal away at night to the local gay clubs so that I could freely express myself, but that is hardly a test of my identity in everyday life. I simply could not say this to myself and believe it to be true.

In conclusion:

There are many thoughts that are capable of keeping a trans person in the closet, and though we only touched upon five I can probably create a novel sized list of them. I guess many of the fallacies I clung to can be attributed to societal expectation, family pressure, and religious upbringing. I truly did feel a ton of guilt regarding my early life choices. I, as many trans people do, wish I would have come out young and stuck to my guns, but life can take you places that aren’t always best, and successfully dealing with difficult change almost always makes someone better.

Image credit: calmenda

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

Brenda Duarte January 6, 2012 at 4:45 pm

This just about sums up my situation to the tee! It did destroy my first marriage, but when I came out to my second wife about two years into the marriage, she was devistated at first, but she is so wonderful, and took the time to really understand. It’s been a rough ride, but she now accepts me for me!! The key is communication.

Reply

Emma January 6, 2012 at 5:19 pm

I’m very happy you were able to find an accepting partner :) They’re hard to find, latch on tight!

Rita January 11, 2012 at 11:11 pm

For myself, I’ve attempted to come out at least 5 times, and fell on my face every time. But the need is still there. The need was there when I came out to my parents at age 9. The need was there when I tried to warn my first wife before we were even dating. And, twenty years later, the need is still there and it is the one thing that keeps me going. I want to be the Real Me at least once before I die.

Reply

Emma January 13, 2012 at 12:29 am

Courage is being afraid, and doing the thing anyway. You WILL get to be you one day, just set some goals and keep moving forward.

Jackie January 31, 2012 at 11:13 pm

I know you’ve heard stories quite similar to mine, but this is all so very new to me. I never though I would have to deal with this in my life. Having said that, I’m the significant other of a crossdresser. See I only met my boyfriend almost 5 months ago. We didn’t even know each other a week before we started dating. He even told me in the beginning that at certain times he likes to dress in women’s clothes. he wears them under his regular clothes out in public. he says he likes the adreneline rush of maybe getting caught. Now I’ve accepted this from the get go because I myself am a Tomboy. I LOVE sports, and hate shopping and “girly” stuff. i also don’t wear girly clothes, but i don’t want to be, feel, or desire to be a man. I’m very attracted to men! I’m not bi-curious either. Sure I’ve kissed a girl or two in my life but it did nothing for me. what bothered me was he would hide things from me. He used to get clothes from other women that he knew before me. and i saw some inappropriate texts on more then

Reply

Jackie January 31, 2012 at 11:24 pm

occasion. and i told him how i felt and he says it’ll never happen again. and to my knowledge it hasn’t. I love my boyfriend more than anything in my world. we both truely believe we were made for each other. but it’s hard for me to get over the whole crossdressing thing. he wants me to pick out “sexy” clothes for him to wear, but just can’t brring myself to do it because I don’t want to be with a woman. and he recently has started to wear more makeup, and then being around “friends” that would ridicule, bully, harm, and do who knows what if they knew what he does. and then i feel they will all look at me like I’m a freak as well. so it upsets me when he leaves the house with “racoon” eyes from mascera and just tries to hide behind a hat pulled low rather then washing his face. we’ve recently had 2 of our close friends ask him if he was wearing makeup, and i covered super quick with the lie that i drew on him while he slept. i just don’t know what to do or how to feel. I love this person with all my heart,

Reply

Emma January 31, 2012 at 11:49 pm

Jackie, it is hard. I am very familiar with that story because I have lived a slightly different version of the other side of it. Embracing him for who he is may make him the happiest person in the world, but do you trust that he is not still keeping things from you? Hiding clothes and makeup is typical behavior, simply because there are many things a crossdresser would have to address in the many conversations following being found out, but the texts bring up other issues that may need to be addressed 8-/. Aside from that, you need to make him be honest with you in a heartfelt conversation. It is very likely that crossdressing is a huge part of what makes him who he is. There is no such thing as a slippery slope here, he is what he is, even if he tries to compromise for you (which won’t be any good down the line, trust me). I have to say that him radically changing his behavior is unlikely, so you have some choices: embrace him for who he is, make him your friend and tell him you can help him dress (but not as a couple), or leave. This is your life too, you absolutely have a choice regarding the people you have a relationship with.

Jackie January 31, 2012 at 11:29 pm

But don’t want to deal with all the drama and narrow minds of our “friends” if they found out. I also am like many women who’s comments I’ve read, and have low self esteem. i’ve never been a pretty, or poular girl. guys wouldn’t date me cuz i was like ‘one of the guys’. but now that I’ve met my boyfriend, I’ve found myself wanting to be more feminine, but feel unsexy, and that he’s thinking of other women when he crossdresses. please help anything will help. sorry rambling on, and my only rescource is the internet on a cheap phone!

Reply

Jackie February 1, 2012 at 12:14 pm

Thank you so much Emma. You’ve taken a huge stress off my shoulders. I haven’t talked to anyone about this and don’t know how either. but one more question what if I do embrace him for who he is but also tell him that I’m just not comfortable with picking clothes out for him? because it’s hard enough just to do it for myself! Thanks again :)

Reply

Kira (Anne) February 1, 2012 at 5:28 pm

Jackie,
Just be honest with him, there are plenty of people who hate shopping for clothes. An upside is that by being open and honest on such a simple issue, it will show that you mean to stick with him even on difficult issues. That is one big fear we all have, that the person we love will still walk out because we dress differently.
As for those “friends”, they were never really friends to start with if they would be cruel regarding such an issue.
As for the texts, that’s a whole different issue, not sure what to tell you.

Emma February 1, 2012 at 5:34 pm

Tell him to shop for his own clothes. That may sound abrasive, but there would be no reason to hide it, should you support him.

avalana February 3, 2012 at 10:01 pm

first be honest to yourself, and you feelings, be honest with your other, accespt him as he is or not! he is likely to be a kind peson at heart… but above all, please forgive ,that is who he is…peace

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: